Heating up

Posted in

Back in September I mentioned that I was thinking about some big home improvement projects. These are driven by a desire to have a warm and toasty house but also reduced bills, with a side helping of being more ecologically sound, but I’m mainly thinking of getting off gas. At the moment gas is much cheaper per kilowatt hour than electricity, but it’s going up and I can’t see it dropping again. Equally the UK government is banning the sale of gas boilers in 2025, which is about when our boiler would be 11 years old and whilst that’s a little early to be replacing ours it’s not too far off.

The problem is, any changes are going to cost. So I want to put my money, time and effort into the best tech available for our English climate, and it’s just not really obvious what that is! So I thought I’d write out what I’m thinking about.

Draft reduction

The first thing I’m looking at is draft reduction. Less hot air lost, less energy needed. But obviously we still need ventilation. I’m thinking mechanical ventilation with heat recovery (MVHR) is the way to go. We currently have four rooms with vents to the outside, and these are rooms that are quite often warmer than other parts of the house. Also, the fans are currently too noisy to leave on most of the time, and I’m aware of drafts back through them when they aren’t on.

To be honest though, we may not get a lot of financial benefit from this, but there are some other considerations. I’m asthmatic, and there’s some evidence that being able to filter the air that comes into the house (at least most of it) could make quite a difference to that. Also, in some of our rooms smells linger and they get musty. I think ventilation would help with these things too.

The down sides? Well, installing venting through the house could well be rather disruptive. We also don’t have space for a ‘control room’ in the house, so the filters (which need to be cleaned/changed every x months) will be more difficult to get to in the loft. And there are very mixed opinions about how useful MVHR is in our climate. Is there much alternative? There are single room heat recovery vents, we could fit those in the bathrooms and just carry on using windows to ventilate I guess? I think if we’re going to add ventilation it only makes sense to try to recover as much heat as possible from the out-going air.

Additionally, I’d really like to up our glazing to triple glazing. We have double-glazing and it’s not old, but I think it was badly fitted. We get drafts in and around a few of the windows which is frustrating. Some of it might be the trickle vents, of course, but that’s another reason to fit MVHR – you don’t need trickle vents if there’s other ventilation.

It won’t be cheap, and it won’t give us much payback. I’m toying with leaving the glazing and just replacing the front door, moving to an external letterbox to get rid of that hole. It might depend on the quotes, I guess.

Heating replacement

So hopefully if we do those things, our base heating requirements will be pretty low. Which is good, because systems like air source heat pumps or ground source heat pumps run at lower temperatures than gas boilers so may need bigger radiators than we currently have, making them even more expensive to install – and they’re not exactly cheap to begin with.

In our case, I think we can rule out ground source heat pumps. We have no access to the back garden for machinery to dig out the trenches, and quite apart from that I like our garden thanks. Vertical boreholes (if that would even fit in our tiny front garden) apparently cost around double, and that’s a bit of a stretch.

So as a direct replacement you then have air source heat pumps, which again we have no obvious position for other than potentially next to our conservatory. This is at the opposite side of the house to the current boiler, and they put out cold air that I’m not sure would be great for the use of the conservatory.

Alternatively we could go for an electric boiler. You can get a straightforward electric combi-boiler, which would solve the other problem we have with hot water. But electric boilers are ‘only’ 100% efficient, unlike air source heat pumps which could be potentially much higher (although not so much when it gets cold, weirdly. Go figure). As a like-for-like (almost) replacement it would be cheap to install, and they cost something like a tenth of the other two options initially.

And then there’s one final contender – infrared panel heaters. Again, ‘only’ 100% efficient, but these panels can be installed in the ceiling and heat almost instantly when required. You could just heat the rooms you’re actually in, rather than the entire house. But these have the downside that they don’t heat the air in the room, so the rooms can cool down again very quickly. Is that a problem if they heat up again quickly too? I’m not sure.

The air source heat pump and the panel heating also both leave us without hot water. Currently we have a combi-boiler, so our hot water is produced on demand. With only two of us we don’t really need a hot water cylinder. So what do we do about that? Again, you can get tankless water heaters, but I’ve only really scratched the surface of looking into those.

To wrap

It’s going to take a few years to get everything actually booked and done regardless of which choice we make, and who knows what the next few years will throw up in terms of tech. Maybe I’ll just put the whole damn lot off, and get the bathroom done instead!


Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *